Men's Champions / Runners of the Year
1993 Haverford, 31 / Steve Monaco, Franklin & Marshall
1994 Haverford, 20 / Karl Paranya, Haverford
1995 Haverford, 23 / Karl Paranya, Haverford
1996 Haverford, 23 / Karl Paranya, Haverford
1997 Haverford, 22 / Ntobeko Ntusi, Haverford
1998 Haverford, 26 / Jason Bernstein, Haverford
1999 Haverford, 25 / Frank McCartney, Franklin & Marshall
2000 Haverford, 19 / J.B. Haglund, Haverford
2001 Haverford, 17 / J.B. Haglund, Haverford

Women's Champions / Runners of the Year
1993 Haverford, 39 / Jen Maranzano, Haverford
1994 Gettysburg, 45 / Jamie Kendig, Franklin & Marshall
1995 Haverford, 44 / Meredith Unger, Haverford
1996 Haverford, 34 / Meredith Unger, Haverford
1997 Dickinson, 32 / Kelly Reynolds, Dickinson
1998 Dickinson, 45 / Rachel Mosher, Haverford
1999 Western Maryland, 53 / Joko Aguynloye, Swarthmore
2000 Dickinson, 34 / Joko Agunloye, Swarthmore
2001 Dickinson, 37 / Kristen Wilson, Haverford